As a CEO, one of your most critical and sometimes most difficult responsibilities is evaluating your sales team performance. Now is the perfect time to take a clear-eyed look at how your team is performing and what adjustments are needed.
Sales team performance isn’t black and white. Some reps might be excelling, while others lag behind. Your job is to identify both, then implement strategies that raise the bar for everyone.
Signs of Sales Underperformance
When sales reps underperform, it usually shows up in the numbers and the behavior. Here are key red flags:
- Missed Quotas – They consistently fall short of targets, even during high-opportunity periods.
- Weak Pipeline – Struggling to keep qualified leads flowing into the funnel.
- Extended Sales Cycles – Deals take longer to close than expected.
- Low Activity Levels – Fewer calls, emails, or booked meetings than benchmarks.
- Disengaged Attitude – Resistance to coaching, negative energy, or low motivation.
How to Address Sales Underperformance
- Find the Root Cause – Is it skill-based? Motivation? Poor fit? Or a broken process? Get specific before trying to fix it.
- Deliver Coaching with Clarity – Use 1:1s, shadowing, and role-plays to develop confidence and address gaps.
- Break Down the Goals – Turn big quotas into weekly or monthly targets. Track and celebrate the wins.
- Train the Team Together – If multiple reps are struggling, it may be a process issue. Group training can reset expectations.
- Make the Hard Calls – If someone’s not turning the corner after support, it might be time to reassign or exit.
Signs of Sales Overperformance
High-performing reps are valuable, but without care, you risk burnout or resentment. Watch for these signs:
- Quota Busters – They’re crushing targets month after month.
- Burnout Warning Signs – Fatigue, stress, or withdrawal.
- Over-Reliance – The business depends too heavily on one or two people.
- Peer Frustration – Tension between top reps and lower performers.
- Hunger for Growth – They ask for leadership or strategic roles.
How to Retain and Grow Top Performers
- Recognize Publicly and Privately – Bonuses, shout-outs, stretch assignments—all matter.
- Offer New Challenges – Give them advanced training or let them lead strategic projects.
- Protect Their Health – Encourage time off, protect their calendar, and manage capacity.
- Use as Peer Mentors – With buy-in, top reps can help raise the bar across the team.
- Invite Them to the Table – Get their input on strategy—great performers often see trends before leadership does.
Balance the Scales
Think of your team as an engine. Every part contributes to sales team performance. Over-relying on a few reps while tolerating underperformance will wear down the whole system. Build a culture of coaching, feedback, and accountability that lifts everyone.
This isn’t a one-time fix…it’s an ongoing process. And you don’t have to tackle it alone.
How Transformative Sales Systems Can Help
At Transformative Sales Systems, we help CEOs like you build, manage, and optimize sales team performance that drive revenue. Whether you’re dealing with inconsistent performers, a lack of process, or no internal sales management at all, our Fractional Sales Management model provides immediate relief and long-term results.
- Implement structured 1:1s and team meetings
- Upgrade your sales process and performance management
- Coach underperformers and retain top talent
- Turn data into action and action into results
Ready to strengthen your sales team?
info@transformativesalessystems.com | 812-924-7085
Schedule a Call
FAQ: Evaluating and Improving Sales Team Performance
- 1. How often should I evaluate my sales team’s performance?
- At a minimum, conduct formal reviews quarterly. However, regular 1:1s and weekly sales meetings provide real-time performance insights.
- 2. What metrics matter most when evaluating performance?
- Look at quota attainment, pipeline health, sales activity levels, win rates, and average deal size. Context matters—don’t just focus on raw numbers.
- 3. What’s the biggest mistake CEOs make when managing sales?
- Letting underperformance drag on too long or relying too heavily on a couple of top reps without building team-wide consistency.
- 4. Can I fix sales performance issues without a sales manager?
- You can try—but most businesses hit a ceiling. Fractional Sales Management fills the gap without the full-time cost.
- 5. What if my best rep is burning out?
- High performers need support too. Offer recognition, protect their time, and find ways to keep them challenged without overloading them.